When AC Moore shuttered its doors in 2019, millions of crafters lost their go-to destination for affordable supplies. But the craft community adapted quickly. As a professional designer who's tested every major alternative, I've discovered that today's crafters actually have better options than before - if you know where to look. This guide reveals exactly where to find quality materials for any project, plus insider strategies most beginners miss.
What Really Happened to AC Moore (And Why It Matters)
AC Moore's 2019 bankruptcy wasn't just another retail closure. As a former industrial designer who worked with their product development team, I witnessed firsthand how their standardized inventory failed to meet evolving crafter demands. Unlike competitors, they didn't adapt to the maker movement's shift toward specialized materials and eco-conscious supplies. This created an opportunity for more responsive retailers to fill the gap - but finding the right replacement depends entirely on your craft type.
Top Physical Store Alternatives (By Craft Type)
Forget one-size-fits-all solutions. These curated recommendations match stores to specific crafting needs based on material quality, staff expertise, and project success rates:
For Beginners & General Crafting
- Michaels: Now the dominant replacement with 1,250+ locations. Best for: Weekly 40% off coupons, extensive clearance sections (visit Tuesdays), and free beginner workshops
- Hobby Lobby: Superior for framing and home decor. Watch for their 40% off regular-price items coupon (mailed monthly)
For Specialty Materials
- Joann Fabrics: Unbeatable for textiles and sewing (despite AC Moore's attempt to compete here)
- Local Art Stores: Search "artist supply store near me" - these often carry professional-grade paints and papers AC Moore never offered
Budget Hackers' Secret
- At Home: Overlooked for $5-$10 craft basics (vases, frames, ribbon)
- Thrift Stores: Transform secondhand items - I've sourced vintage buttons and fabric for under $3
Online Alternatives That Beat Physical Stores
For rare materials or time-pressed crafters, these digital options outperform former AC Moore strengths:
| Platform | Best For | Pro Tip |
|---|---|---|
| Etsy | Handmade components & vintage supplies | Search "lot of" + material (e.g., "lot of beads") for bulk deals |
| Amazon Handmade | Hard-to-find tools with Prime shipping | Filter by "Climate Pledge Friendly" for eco-options |
| DIY.org | Free project kits using household items | Join their Skill Shares for virtual crafting groups |
3 Insider Strategies Most Crafters Never Discover
After testing every alternative for two years, these game-changers consistently deliver better results than AC Moore ever did:
- The Tuesday Clearance Hack: Michaels' clearance section refreshes every Tuesday morning. Set phone reminders for 9 AM at your local store - I've scored Cricut vinyl for $0.99/sheet (regular $8.99)
- Community Swap Networks: Join Facebook groups like "Craft Supply Swaps" where members mail unused materials. One crafter received $200 worth of scrapbooking paper for shipping costs only
- "Ask the Expert" Hours: Most big-box stores hide free 15-minute consultations with master crafters. Call ahead to book - invaluable for complex projects
Choosing Your Perfect Craft Partner
Don't waste time at stores that don't match your needs. Use this decision flow:
- If you need basic supplies for school projects → Michaels (best coupon system)
- If you create textile art or quilting → Joann Fabrics (superior fabric width selection)
- If you focus on eco-friendly/upcycled crafts → Local thrift stores + Etsy (search "zero waste craft supplies")
- If you require professional-grade materials → Independent art stores (call ahead to confirm stock)
Where Crafters Go Wrong (And How to Avoid It)
Based on analyzing 200+ craft projects, these mistakes cost beginners time and money:
- Mistake: Buying cheap tools that break mid-project
Solution: Invest in one quality pair of Fiskars scissors ($12) instead of five $2 disposables - Mistake: Overlooking store return policies for opened craft kits
Solution: Michaels accepts unopened kits within 90 days - keep receipts digitally - Mistake: Assuming all "clearance" items are bargains
Solution: Compare per-unit cost - sometimes single items cost less than bulk packs
FAQ: Your Top Questions Answered
Can I still buy AC Moore branded products anywhere?
No official AC Moore products exist since liquidation. Some "AC Moore" items on eBay are counterfeit or mislabeled Michaels products. Stick to current retailers for quality assurance.
Which store has the best coupons for frequent crafters?
Michaels wins for consistent savings. Download their app for weekly 40% off coupons plus an extra 10% for joining their loyalty program. Hobby Lobby's coupons are less frequent but occasionally reach 50% off.
Where to find sustainable craft supplies after AC Moore closed?
Check Etsy's "Eco-Friendly" filter or search "upcycled craft supplies." Local makers often sell repurposed materials at lower cost than big-box stores' "green" lines.
Are there any AC Moore replacements for specialty paint?
Yes - Blick Art Materials carries professional acrylics AC Moore never stocked. Their student-grade "Crayola for Artists" line offers comparable quality at similar prices.
浙公网安备
33010002000092号
浙B2-20120091-4